Wednesday, October 28, 2009
Energy Economics and EROI
A lower EROI means higher real energy costs, ceteris paribus. If it fell to 1 or below, production could only be sustained with inputs being cheaper than outputs. In so far as energy is conservable or substitutable, it will be as costs rise. In so far as it is not, its price will be fixed by its marginal productivity. The economy will survive, but it could be a very different economy from the one we have, one where long distant trade and travel declines, one where energy use becomes an active consideration rather than an afterthought. Technology will help ward off this future, more so in conservation than in production, but it would take a new industrial revolution to substantially reverse it. Possible, but not one you can predict, and a high risk strategy to rely on, as the industrial revolution may not have even occurred without lower real energy costs.
Monday, September 7, 2009
Macro Economic Instablity
Is the macroeconomy inherently unstable? Is it only through monetary and fiscal policies that it is stabilized? This is the intriguing question of a post of Nick Rowe. As much as I believe there should be, I cannot think of any reason to be so. My first thought was assets, debt, and equity, through cash flow, give mass to the body of income, and this could at least limit swings in income, on the negative side by assets providing positive cash flow and on the positive side by assets appreciating faster than increases in cash flow. Asset values swing, debt defaults rise and fall, equity shifts, and cash flow with them though. While they may swing differently from other income sources, it does not seem it would provide much if any stabilization.
There seems to be a finite amount of useful work at any given time, and this amount may fall sharply should a significant amount of it be found unuseful. Useful is in the sense of covering costs and profits. Cutting wages doesn't make more useful work any more than cutting prices does if costs and profits cannot be covered. One could redistribute the remaining work among more workers, but this would not increase overall income without other changes. What is needed is the creation of new useful work generating new income, but this is a slow difficult process. The economy may range from a deluge of innovation with an abundance of new useful work to be done to a dearth of innovation with a lack of new useful work, or from innovation that creates new useful work to innovation that destroys existing useful work. There is no assurance of a balance of work and workers in the short or even long term because there is no assurance of a balance in the occurence of innovation.
There seems to be a finite amount of useful work at any given time, and this amount may fall sharply should a significant amount of it be found unuseful. Useful is in the sense of covering costs and profits. Cutting wages doesn't make more useful work any more than cutting prices does if costs and profits cannot be covered. One could redistribute the remaining work among more workers, but this would not increase overall income without other changes. What is needed is the creation of new useful work generating new income, but this is a slow difficult process. The economy may range from a deluge of innovation with an abundance of new useful work to be done to a dearth of innovation with a lack of new useful work, or from innovation that creates new useful work to innovation that destroys existing useful work. There is no assurance of a balance of work and workers in the short or even long term because there is no assurance of a balance in the occurence of innovation.
Thursday, August 27, 2009
Peak Oil
Does the long term real price of oil look like it is falling? Sure it may have fallen after the peak in the 70s and again recently, but overall it is up. Oil at $20 is likely gone forever. Oil at $30 is largely gone and unlikely to be seen other than briefly. Oil at $40 or $50 we should see until the next shortage drives another spike in oil prices. We have been able to extract more, but not more cheaply. We will use less, because it is more expensive. We will develop alternatives, because oil will eventually be more expensive than those alternatives. The only way it will fall in price over the long run is if it is displaced and no longer wanted.
Tuesday, August 25, 2009
Dividing the Division of Labor
The division of labor can produce higher quality output and do so more efficiently but only by a limited amount. Labor has specialized since the beginning of civilization but produced only infinitesimal growth. Only the application of scientific knowledge and the advent of powered machinery produced modern levels of growth. This has led to greater specialization but there is little reason to attribute growth to this beyond its embodiment in knowledge and technology. The real usefulness of the division of labor is not in labor at all but in gaining specialized knowledge and replacing labor with technology, automating production.
Thursday, August 20, 2009
Two Centuries of Growth
The Growth of Real Income (real gdp per capita) in the US demonstrates the transition from an agrarian to industrial to post industrial power. Growth was slow initially but rose over the 19th century in fits and starts. It would rise sharply during booms only to stagnate or fall slightly through busts lasting a decade or more. A dramatic fall occurred over 1929 to 1933 followed by as dramatic a rise climaxing during World War II before settling back to extended consistent growth at the best rates ever. Variability has diminished somewhat over time. Most deviations are small from this upward drift over history. Growth appears to have reached an asymptote of about a factor of 10 per century or about 2.3% a year. So much for past golden ages.
Thursday, July 23, 2009
Deflation is Depressing
Is deflation always bad? Some industries exhibit falling prices which are beneficial to consumers, so if deflation leads to most falling that should be good as well, right? No. Deflation leads to a riskless real return on money. This is bad for the economy as any investment that returns less than that, or even more than that but carries some risk is not made, and growth slows to reduce that return to zero. Falling prices lead to delayed sales and raises real debt burdens slowing the economy further and leading to more deflation. The economy has difficulty adjusting to deflation due to the lack of expectations and sticky prices, creating a vicious cycle. In a perfect world with known expectations and all planning, contracts, and prices adjusted seamlessly, deflation would not present a problem, but in such a world neither would it be necessary, and as prices must respond to supply and demand rather than uniformly, resistance and stickiness would remain. In the end, deflation is depressing.
Thursday, July 16, 2009
Unbelievable
A really nice paper on the unsustainability of the bubble is this 2006 paper by Robert Parenteau, US Household Deficit Spending. We were well into Minsky's ponzi finance regime where debt is acquired to pay off previous debt leading to a debt trap. Even if income increased with productivity, it could not sustain debt rising with asset values. Finance wasn't growing with the economy, it was the growth of the economy, it was growing at the expense of the economy. This is why it is so unbelievable so many failed to see it coming. They had to close their eyes really tightly.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)